BMW X3 vs Toyota Highlander
The BMW X3 makes more power, while the Toyota Highlander starts about $8,050 lower and returns better fuel economy. Here is how the two compare on the numbers that decide most purchases.
| Measure | BMW X3 | Toyota Highlander |
|---|---|---|
| Price rangeOriginal sticker prices across all trims. | $38,500–$65,900 | $30,450–$56,000✓ |
| Years covered | 2015–2026 | 2015–2026 |
| Fuel economyBest figure quoted across the range. | 30 mpg | 35 mpg✓ |
| Power | 393 hp✓ | 306 hp |
| Cargo space | 31.5 cu ft | — |
| Seats | 5 | 5 |
| Fuel types | Petrol, Diesel, Hybrid | Petrol |
| Drivetrains | RWD, AWD | AWD, FWD |
| Safety rating | Not rated (NHTSA) | — |
| Reliability | — | — |
| Insurance (yr) | — | — |
| Resale value | — | — |
| Recalls | 1 recall (2026) | 9 recalls (2023–2025) |
BMW X3 vs Toyota Highlander: common questions
Is the BMW X3 cheaper than the Toyota Highlander?
No — the Toyota Highlander has the lower entry price. The BMW X3 spans $38,500–$65,900 and the Toyota Highlander spans $30,450–$56,000, based on original sticker prices across all trims.
Which is more fuel efficient, the BMW X3 or the Toyota Highlander?
The Toyota Highlander is more efficient, quoting 35 mpg against 30 mpg for the other.
Which should I buy, the BMW X3 or the Toyota Highlander?
It depends on what you weight most. The BMW X3 makes more power, while the Toyota Highlander starts about $8,050 lower and returns better fuel economy. Here is how the two compare on the numbers that decide most purchases. Cars4Real shows both cars' full trim tables, owner reviews, safety records and depreciation so you can judge against your own priorities rather than a generic verdict.